Defense Base Act and War Hazard Compensation Act Program August 27, 2026
- The Defense Base Act (DBA) primarily covers employees: (1) working for private employers on U.S. military bases; (2) working on public work contracts with any U.S. government agency; and (3) working for American employers providing welfare or similar services outside of the U.S. for the benefit of the Armed Forces.
- The War Hazards Compensation Act (WHCA) is a subset of the DBA. The WHCA provides compensation for federal contractors working on U.S. installations overseas to compensation for injuries sustained on the job from a "war hazard." A "war hazard" is statutorily defined as “any hazard arising during a war in which the United States is engaged; during an armed conflict in which the United States is engaged, whether or not war has been declared; or during a war or armed conflict between military forces of any origin, occurring within any country in which a person covered by this chapter is serving.” Importantly, under the WHCA, the U.S. Government bears the financial obligation for any war hazard related injuries suffered by covered employees.
- This program is unique not only because of the U.S. foreign interests involved, but because the program links and runs across four of the most important agencies within the U.S. Government: the Departments of State, War [Defense], Labor, and Treasury.
- The Department of Labor (DoL), specifically its Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs, does not directly handle or pay DBA or WHCA claims. Authorized DBA insurers handle, adjudicate, and pay DBA claims as part of the DBA coverage provided to employers. For WHCA claims, while the U.S. Government has the ultimate financial obligation for these claims, the private DBA insurers serve as intermediaries between the U.S. Government and claimants and handle, adjudicate, and pay these claims on behalf of the U.S. Government.
- Since 2011, Starr has handled over 32,500 DBA and WHCA claims; of which 24,500 of arose following the Afghanistan withdrawal. Further, of these 24,500 claims, over 13,000 involve Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). In total, Starr has paid over $2.5 billion for DBA and WHCA claims.
- Starr can collect premium for its DBA coverage. Starr does not collect premium for WHCA claims since the U.S. Government has the ultimate financial obligation for WHCA claims; rather, Starr is statutorily permitted to seek reimbursement of WHCA benefits paid to claimants and the DoL is statutorily required to pay such reimbursements.
- Starr maintains loss run and related claim information that is utilized for multiple purposes,
and the information therefore contains different data points and labels relevant for these
purposes. Because premium calculation is only one such use of the loss run information,
the information contains other data points not used to calculate premium.
- When undertaking premium calculations, Starr removes claims that fall or may fall under the WHCA from the loss run information.
-
Starr categorizes claims with separate designations, inclusive of (1) claims that only
have WHCA benefits, and (2) mixed claims that include both DBA and WHCA
benefits. Within Starr’s claims information spreadsheet, claims are categorized into
two columns: “WHCA I” and “WHCA II.”
- If a claim does not have any war hazard component, Starr marks each category with “N/A.” Starr can use these non-war hazard DBA claims in calculating premium.
- If a claim involves a war hazard injury, Starr marks the “WHCA I” column with “WHCA,” and if it is a mixed claim that includes both DBA and WHCA benefits, the “WHCA II” column is marked with the applicable reason for the war hazard designation (often, “PTSD”). If a claim involves any war hazard component, or has a “WHCA” marker in the “WHCA I” column of the spreadsheet, it is not used in calculating premium.
- Starr meticulously maintains its internal data and either removes or separates any claims involving WHCA to ensure premium is not calculated based on WHCA claims experience.
- When handling DBA and WHCA claims, Starr undertakes a thorough analysis of each claim and adjudicates the claim based on its specific facts. This work includes, among other actions, securing and reviewing all relevant and past medical records, confirming coverage for losses, arranging and assessing independent medical evaluations, retaining and paying for outside counsel, managing litigation, conducting all necessary discovery, mediating and/or negotiating settlements, and, ultimately, if applicable, paying benefits. PTSD claims require even further analysis, including comprehensive medical verification and additional investigation due to the nature of the alleged injuries.
- If Starr believes a claim is suspicious or fraudulent, Starr conducts further investigation into the claim, and, if warranted, the claim is brought to the attention of the DoL or the relevant Administrative Law Judge (ALJ).
- After a claim is settled or adjudicated by hearing, the DoL or the assigned ALJ must review and approve the settlement. That review includes analysis of all relevant documents and information. Only after the DoL or ALJ approves the settlement can a payment be made by Starr to the claimant.
- Following payment of a WHCA claim, to receive reimbursement, Starr must provide all relevant documents to the DoL for review. The DoL then undertakes another independent review of all relevant documents and the settlement or payment itself. Only after the DoL reviews, validates and approves of the payment – most often for the second time – is Starr entitled to reimbursement, which is ultimately paid to Starr from the Treasury Department. This WHCA claims reimbursement review and payment process can, and often does, take years for the U.S. Government to complete.
- Through the comprehensive processes outlined above, Starr can only make DBA and WHCA payments to claimants after the DoL or ALJ approves of the payment. Then, Starr can only receive reimbursement for WHCA claims after a second approval by the DoL.
- Starr has engaged with the DoL over the last five years regarding the growing and significant backlog in WHCA claim reimbursements. The DoL currently owes Starr hundreds of millions for WHCA claims paid to individual claimants on behalf of the U.S. Government, dating back nearly a decade. Despite the significant WHCA claims reimbursement backlog that all DBA carriers are facing, the DoL has not made any significant process improvements. The DoL’s processing delays have resulted in Starr floating an enormous, interest-free loan to the U.S. Government, and depriving Starr the opportunity to earn interest income on these funds.